DuBose Denies Preliminary Injunctions for Pinion and Simpson

Joe Pinion and Derek Simpson will not play for Providence this season unless something changes above Judge Melissa R. DuBose’s courtroom. In a joint Memorandum and Order issued Friday, DuBose denied both players’ motions for a preliminary injunction, holding that they had not established a likelihood of success on the breach of contract claim that was the sole basis for the motions.


“For the reasons discussed below, the Court concludes that the Plaintiffs have not established a likelihood of success and, thus, their Motions are denied,” DuBose wrote.

Pinion and Simpson sued the NCAA on October 8th after the NCAA ruled both ineligible for the 2026-27 season. Each played four seasons from 2022 through 2026, Simpson at Rutgers and Saint Joseph’s and Pinion at Arkansas State and South Florida for current Friars head coach Bryan Hodgson. Both enrolled at Providence over the summer expecting a fifth season under the NCAA’s new 5-in-5 rule, which was passed June 24, 2026 and took effect August 1, 2026. The NCAA’s position from the start has been that the rule does not reach athletes who had already exhausted their eligibility when it took effect. DuBose denied the players’ motions for a temporary restraining order on October 22nd and Friday’s ruling ends the injunction phase of the cases.


The players’ contract argument had two steps: that they are intended third-party beneficiaries of the NCAA Manual, and that the plain text of Bylaw 12.6 makes them eligible. DuBose gave them the first step, at least provisionally. “At the MPI stage where Plaintiffs need only establish a likelihood of success on the merits, the Court is going to assume without deciding that these Plaintiffs are intended third-party beneficiaries of the contract,” she wrote.


The case turned on the second step and on how much of the contract a court is allowed to read. The players argued that Bylaw 12.6 should be applied as written and that the limiting language in the rule’s Adopted Final legislation is commentary that was never incorporated into the Manual. DuBose agreed with half of that framing. “If Bylaw 12.6 is read in a vacuum, the Court agrees that Plaintiffs are eligible to play,” she wrote. “But the Court cannot ignore the rest of Bylaw 12 and read Bylaw 12.6 in isolation.”
Rhode Island law, she held, requires reading the contract as a whole, and the Manual’s own provisions point beyond the four corners of Bylaw 12.6. Bylaw 12.01.1 conditions eligibility on meeting “the athletics eligibility legislation and interpretation,” and the Manual states that its legislation lives in the NCAA’s Legislative Services Database and is updated to reflect adopted legislation. On that basis the court held the Adopted Final legislation is part of the contract and the Adopted Final text says the 5-in-5 rule “may be applied to student-athletes with eligibility remaining (seasons and period of eligibility) who initially enrolled full time in any collegiate institution before August 1, 2026.”
That sentence decided the case. “This is where Plaintiffs’ attempt at securing eligibility for this season is doomed,” DuBose wrote. “Considering the plain language of the contract in its entirety, including the Bylaws, legislation, and interpretations, neither Simpson nor Pinion are eligible to take advantage of the 5-in-5 Rule because, when the new rule was enacted and took effect, neither had ‘eligibility remaining.’”
The court also addressed Helms v. NCAA, the District of Idaho case the players flagged in a notice of supplemental authority after the November 10th hearing. The Idaho court had found a likelihood of success on the same contract claim by staying with the plain text of Bylaw 12.6. DuBose acknowledged the split and declined to follow it: “While this Court agrees that Bylaw 12.6 on its own appears to be plain and unambiguous, Rhode Island law warns against reading contract provisions in isolation and instructs the courts to read provisions at issue in the context of the entire contract.”
Two loose ends from the briefing got answers as well. The players had argued that the word “may” in the Adopted Final text left the NCAA discretion to apply the rule to them. The court read “may” differently: the rule “does not bar all athletes from the high school class of 2022, just those who do not have eligibility remaining,” which is what the word accounts for. And because likelihood of success failed, the court declined to weigh the remaining injunction factors at all, citing First Circuit precedent. “Plaintiffs have not carried their burden and therefore the Motions for Preliminary Injunction are denied.”


What remains is narrower than what the players asked for in October, but the cases are not over. The preliminary injunction motions pressed only the contract claim. As the order itself puts it, the motions left “the Sherman Act claim on the bench,” and that antitrust claim is still alive, with the court keeping supplemental jurisdiction over the contract claim alongside it. A preliminary injunction ruling is also a prediction rather than a final merits decision, and denials of preliminary injunctions can be appealed to the First Circuit as of right. Whether Pinion and Simpson take that route is the next news to watch. On the NCAA’s pending motion to dismiss, the players’ responses are now due November 25th and replies November 27th after the court granted an extension earlier on Friday.

The order also noted, without holding it against him, that this was Simpson’s third attempt at relief, after a Pennsylvania court denied him a preliminary injunction following an evidentiary hearing and a North Carolina case was filed and dismissed. The court exercised jurisdiction over his claim anyway.


For Providence, the roster question that has hung over the program since October is settled for practical purposes. The Friars are 4-1 without either player and head to the Maui Invitational next week. Pinion and Simpson have been with the team since the summer, and absent an appeal that lands quickly or a merits win later in the case, their Providence careers will have ended before either one played a minute.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *